
New revelations about the Bush Administration's extrordinary rendition program continue to emerge. In Italy, 26 CIA agents have been named - including Robert Seldon Lady, the reputed CIA station chief - in a case that continues to have wide-ranging implications both in Italy and in the U.S. In Germany, a similar case involving extrordinary renditions by CIA agents is also coming to fruition. And both Poland and Romania continue to deny having hosted secret CIA prisons despite overwhelming evidence that points to their active collusion in these illegal activities.
The extrordinary rendition program was designed to abduct suspected terrorists and then transfer, or render, them to third countries - like Egypt, Morocco, Syria, Jordan, and Thailand - whose police often have established reputations for employing torture on interrogation subjects. The problem - aside from moral considerations and questions about the reliability of information obtained under torture - is that transferring people to countries where there's a likelihood that they will be tortured is illegal under the Geneva Conventions. The U.S. Senate long ago ratified these treaties, meaning that those who participated in these renditions would be guilty of breaking international law.
While the outlines of this story are generally well-known, though, the story of how this information originally came to light is just as interesting but is itself far less well-known.
One source of this information came from investigative journalists like London-based Stephen Grey, who has recently written a book,
Ghost Plane: The True Story of the CIA Torture Program, that details the means by which this story was slowly uncovered.
In order to transport terrorism suspects, the CIA bought and operated a number of airplanes, including a Gulfstream V and a Boeing 737 Business jet, that could fly into small airports far more inconspicuously than a military plane could. The problem with using civilian-registered airplanes, however, is that each time these jets fly, they have to record their flight plan with the FAA in the U.S., or similar agencies in other countries around the world.
And, interestingly enough, all of these FAA records are publicly available, so that industrious journalists like Grey can follow the path of a particular plane over weeks, months, or even years. And much of this information, in one form or another, then becomes available on the internet to similarly interested individuals.
Grey's book provides a fascinating look at some of the methods he used to uncover the extrordinary rendition story. By checking with the FAA’s website, not only could flight logs be obtained, but information about the plane’s ownership could be found too. This information in turn could be used as another strand for investigating the names of owners, who were then discovered to be fictitious, their names having been brought into existence around the time of the incorporation of the front company.
Furthermore, Grey took the mountain of information he obtained for the most part from on-line sources and used a computer program called Analyst’s Notebook, a tool normally used by the police to solve complex financial crimes, to piece together the story of the extraordinary rendition program.
One of the most interesting aspects of these investigative methods, though, is that many are made possible - or at least significantly easier - as a result of new technologies that weren't available 30 years ago during the era of Air America.
As such, Grey's story of helping uncover the extrordinary rendition program can be seen as a harbinger of the types of journalistic stories that are at least facilitated, if not made possible, by new and emerging technologies. Beyond that, though, Grey's story in
Ghost Plane can be seen as a blueprint for other types of stories that are now, or will soon be, available that had in the past remained quietly out of public sight.
In Part II of this entry, we'll take a look at how two other journalists, Trevor Paglen and A.C. Thompson, used very different but nonetheless similarly high-tech methods to write their own story about the extrordinary rendition program.
Ghost Plane is avaialble at amazon.com.